Which of the following is logically equivalent?
A. ¬p → (q → r) and q → (p ∨ r)
B. (p → q) → r and p → (q → r)
C. (p → q) → (r → s) and (p → r) → (q → s)
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Solution
A. ¬p → (q → r) and q → (p ∨ r)
For the above, we can make a truth table and compare them:
| p |
q |
r |
¬p |
q → r |
¬p → (q → r) |
p v r |
q → (p v r) |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
- We can see that both are equal, hence, they are equivalent.
B. (p → q) → r and p → (q → r)
For the above, we can make a truth table and compare them:
| p |
q |
r |
p → q |
(p → q) → r |
q → r |
p → (q → r) |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
- We can see that both are not equal, hence, they are not equivalent.
C. (p → q) → (r → s) and (p → r) → (q → s)
For the above, we can make a truth table and compare them:
| p |
q |
r |
s |
p → q |
r → s |
(p → q)→(r → s) |
p → r |
q → s |
(p → r)→(q → s) |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
| TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
TRUE |
FALSE |
FALSE |
| FALSE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
TRUE |
- We can see that both are not equal, hence, they are not equivalent.